Why the Scales Aren’t the Best Way to Measure Your Progress

You’ve been training regularly. You’re feeling stronger. Your clothes are fitting better. You have more energy.

Then you step on the scales.

Nothing has changed.

It can be incredibly frustrating — and it’s one of the reasons people sometimes convince themselves that their exercise programme “isn’t working.”

But the problem may not be your progress.

The problem may be how you’re measuring it.

Your Weight Is Just One Number

The scales tell you how much your body weighs at that particular moment.

They don’t tell you how strong you are.

They don’t tell you whether you’ve gained muscle.

They don’t tell you whether your waist measurement has changed.

And they certainly don’t tell you whether you can now squat, lift, walk, climb stairs or get through your day more easily than you could a few months ago.

Body weight can also fluctuate naturally from day to day because of hydration, food intake and other factors.

So while the scales can be useful, they’re only one piece of the picture.

Your Body Can Change Without a Big Change on the Scales

This is particularly important when you start strength training.

With consistent training, you may become stronger and improve your body composition even when your overall body weight doesn’t change dramatically.

Imagine someone who starts training at 75kg.

A few months later, they’re still around 75kg.

Looking only at the scales, they might think:

“I haven’t made any progress.”

But perhaps their waist is smaller.

Their clothes fit differently.

They’re lifting considerably more weight.

They can perform exercises they struggled with when they started.

They have more energy.

And they feel much more confident physically.

Would we really call that no progress?

Of course not.

Strength Is Progress

One of the easiest improvements to overlook is also one of the most important:

You’re getting stronger.

Maybe you started goblet squatting with 6kg and you’re now comfortably using 14kg.

Perhaps you couldn’t perform a controlled push-up when you started, but now you can.

Maybe the weights you once found intimidating have become your warm-up weights.

That is measurable progress.

Resistance training improves muscular strength and function, which is one reason muscle-strengthening exercise is recommended as part of a healthy, active lifestyle.

And unlike the scales, your training performance can tell us something very useful:

your body is becoming more capable.

Look at Your Measurements

Another useful way to monitor progress is through body measurements.

Waist, hips, arms and thighs can all provide additional information that body weight alone can’t give you.

This is particularly useful when someone’s goal includes changing their body composition.

You might only lose a small amount of body weight but see a noticeable change around your waist.

That matters.

In fact, health organisations don’t rely solely on body weight when assessing health. Waist circumference is another commonly used measurement because where body fat is stored can also be important.

Again, the message is simple:

Don’t allow one number to tell the whole story.

Pay Attention to How Your Clothes Fit

This isn’t particularly scientific — but it’s extremely useful.

The trousers that were tight three months ago suddenly feel comfortable.

You move a belt in another notch.

A shirt fits differently around your waist.

These are real-world signs that something is changing.

And often people notice these changes before they see the number they were hoping for on the scales.

Notice What Everyday Life Feels Like

Progress doesn’t only happen inside the gym.

Sometimes the best signs appear when you’re not thinking about exercise at all.

Carrying the shopping feels easier.

Getting up from the floor isn’t such an effort.

You walk up a flight of stairs without thinking about it.

You can play with your children without getting tired as quickly.

Your back doesn’t feel as stiff after sitting at your desk.

You feel more confident lifting something heavy.

These improvements might never appear on your bathroom scales.

But they can make an enormous difference to your life.

Consistency Is Progress Too

There is another measure we think deserves much more attention:

showing up consistently.

If you previously exercised for two weeks, stopped for a month and then started again, but you’ve now trained consistently two or three times every week for several months, that’s a significant change.

You’ve built a habit.

And long-term results are built on habits far more than short bursts of motivation.

Sometimes the first victory isn’t losing 5kg.

It’s becoming someone who trains every week.

So Should You Throw Away the Scales?

Not necessarily.

If losing body fat is one of your goals, monitoring your weight can still provide useful information.

But look at the trend over time, rather than becoming emotionally attached to individual weigh-ins.

More importantly, combine your weight with other measures of progress.

At Infinite Change Fitness, we like to look at the bigger picture:

  • Are you getting stronger?
  • Are your measurements changing?
  • Has your body composition changed?
  • Are you training consistently?
  • Are you moving better?
  • Do your clothes fit differently?
  • How do you feel?
  • Are everyday activities becoming easier?

Put all of those together and you get a much better picture of what’s actually happening.

Progress Is Bigger Than a Number

It’s completely understandable to want to see the number on the scales go down.

But don’t let that number erase everything else you’ve achieved.

If you’re stronger than you were three months ago, that’s progress.

If you’re moving better, that’s progress.

If you’ve lost centimetres from your waist, that’s progress.

If you’ve gone from avoiding exercise to training three times every week, that’s progress.

And if you’re doing things today that you couldn’t do when you started?

That’s definitely progress.

The scales can give you information.

Just don’t give them the power to decide whether you’re succeeding.


Infinite Change Fitness
Real People. Real Change. Infinite Possibilities.

About the Author

Mike Watt is Co-Founder and Head Coach at Infinite Change Fitness in Abu Dhabi, helping adults build strength, confidence and lasting results through expert coaching and supportive small-group training.

START YOUR JOURNEY

Ready to Build Strength and Confidence?

The 12 Week Strength Foundation is designed for adults who want expert coaching, accountability and a supportive community to help them become stronger, fitter and more confident.

Helping adults in Abu Dhabi build strength, confidence and lasting results.

You May Also Like